Hey everyone, I chose to do scenario 6 for this activity:
John and his friend Mike both have camera phones. Mike sits in the back of his class and uses his phone to photograph the test for John, who is taking the test that afternoon. Mike then emails the photograph to the test to John's phone (Ribble, 2011).
Well, it is very obvious that Mike and his friend John are using technology inappropriately. To begin, Mike is using his phone during a test. The phone he has not only can be used to take pictures but can also connect to the internet and he can have access to sites that might have the answers to the test questions. Today, math classes are allowing more and more students to use their phones as their calculator instead of using a calculator bought from the store. I understand why they do this to save the students money, but it is hard for a teacher to regulate what students are doing on their phones 24/7 especially during a test. Secondly, Mike is giving his friend John the test before he does it, which is cheating. Technology is supposed to help you develop skills to complete tasks in school, and if used abusively, like in this scenario, makes a bad name for technology not to mention the student is not learning anything. In the article, "Cell phones in school" they address the point that it is unhealthy for students to depend excessively on their cell phones. The point of tests is to assess YOUR skills and not the internet's skills. Knowing the test in advanced, teaches the student nothing. I think that the underlying issue here is that students need to be taught how to use technology properly in the classroom. As the article "From toy to tool: Cell phones in the classroom" explains, teachers do not want to be responsible for harmful mobile behaviour. It is important to teach cell phone etiquette. I am a believer of technology being used in the classroom, and by addressing proper digital rights and responsibilities of technology will help students understand proper use of technology. Mike should have put his phone away and gave his friend John hints about what was on the test and not fully tell him. As suggested by "From toy to tool: Cell phones in the classroom" , it is important that the teacher set rules about using phones as calculators in the classroom.
The article "from toy to tool: Cell phones in the classroom" also offers some good ways to address cell phones etiquette. Do you have any that you would like to add? feel free to tell me :)
Thanks for reading!
Missemilyp
Hey Emily!
ReplyDeleteI really liked your response to the scenario. I know at Brock that the accounting department's reaction has been to band the use of cell phones during tests and exams. If a student is caught with a cell phone in a test or exam setting, it will result in an automatic grade of zero on that test or exam which I see as a fairly strong deterrent.
Cheers,
-S
Thanks for the reply!
ReplyDeleteYes, in the math department at Brock they have done the same thing. They do not allow any cell phones at all and I think that high schools should start making students aware that in University cell phones are not allowed to be used for calculators and they should encourage them to buy a calculator to avoid future problems.
Emily
Hi Emily,
ReplyDeleteGreat post! I completely agree the use of technology in this scenario is completely inappropriate. I'm surprised the student got away with using the cell phone during the test in the first place - this is an example of bad enforcement of an AUP in the school for sure! Both students are using technology to cheat, which is not ethical in any sense. I think John should be given a completely different test because he was writing it at a different time than the rest of the students - this gives both students the chance to right a fair test and encourages students to study hard!
Great discussion,
ColleenA.
Hello Emily,
ReplyDeleteI agree that the students use of his cellphone during the test was completely inappropriate, and John/Mike are only cheating themselves in the long run. I think a way to solve this is for the classroom to have enough calculators to provide to the students, so they do not need the use of phones. You could also have the people spaced out so it would be easier to see if anyone is cheating. At the end of the day though if someone wants to cheat on a test/assignment they will find a way, but the students needs to know it might benefit you now, but you gain nothing in the long run.
Great Post Emily!!
-Ali
Hey Emily,
ReplyDeleteGreat Post! I completely agree with you. Students should not be able to use cell phones on tests or exams and in class in general. Like Ali said above, "if someone wants to cheat on a test/assignment they will.... but they gain nothing in the long run", this is very true. There is only so much a teacher can do to prevent cheating and if the student does it then they were too lazy to study or just don't care. Hopefully students will become smarter with their cell phones but with technology continuing to change, who knows what will happen.
-Lauren
Hey Emily,
ReplyDeleteI completely agree this is an inappropriate use of technology. Technology is supposed to enhance our learning but using in these types of ways hinders learning. I am very surprised that Mike was able to bring his cell phone into the test. I know in test I have not been able to use a programmable calculator and a cell phone would definitely be out of the question.
Great job,
Olivia
Hi Emily,
ReplyDeleteI could not agree more with your analyses of this scenario. Mike should not be using his phone to send John pictures of a test that he is about to take as it is extremely inappropriate. Not only does it give John an unfair advantage in comparison to other students in the class (who have probably studied and prepared for this test thoroughly), but it also is not an ethical use of technology. I do not believe that any student should be allowed to use their cell phone during a test because, like you said, students could search for answers on the internet. I also agree with you in that students should learn how to properly use technology so it can enhance their learning and teach them the benefits of technology in education.
Cheers,
Lisa R